Wednesday, February 4, 2009

February 4 - "The Phonebook Man"

“The Phonebook Man”
by Bentley Little
The Collection (2002)

* * (Okay) Suspense

Nina answers the door early in the morning to find a phonebook salesman peddling on her front step. The smallest kindness – the use of the bathroom – lands Nina a guest she can’t shake loose.

There are some unexplained occurrences - namely what happens when the phonebook man emerges from the bathroom - that ground this story to a halt. They are not explained, and the glaringly “huh?” moments should never be left unaccounted for. The idea of a guest overstaying his welcome is not new, but Little does manage a fine job of constructing fear and suspense that feels true to Nina. However, there were simply too many unanswered questions and puzzling moments for this story to shine for me.

1 comment:

Escape Pirate said...

In his short introduction to the story, Little does mention that this phonebook man is a supernatural being. I suppose it does explain - barely - what occurs in the bathroom, but if you weren't given that introductory paragraph, how would you ever know?